The Chinese negation marker bu and its association with focus* PEPPINA LEE PO-LUN and PAN HAIHUA
نویسنده
چکیده
The Chinese negation marker bu ‘not’ is analyzed as a clitic-like element in the literature (Huang 1988; Ernst 1995; etc.) in order to explain why it cannot co-occur with (i) the perfective marker -le or (ii) manner phrases in the V-de construction. Huang (1988) assumes that bu must cliticize onto auxiliaries/modals or the following verb, and since bu cliticizing directly to a verb induces a ‘‘nonevent’’ that is semantically incompatible with -le and manner phrases, facts (i) and (ii) are thus accounted for. Grammatical sentences without auxiliaries/modals are assumed to have an empty modal with future or volitional meaning, giving bu the meaning won’t. Unlike Huang, Ernst (1995) argues that bu is proclitic on the adjacent word. He explains facts (i) and (ii), respectively, by the boundedness conflict between bu, assumed to occur only with unbounded situations, and perfective -le that requires bounded situations, and by assuming that the XP trace of a manner phrase between bu and the verb prevents bu from cliticizing to any lexical element, leading to ungrammatical sentences. However, closer examination shows that bu can co-occur with both manner phrases in the V-de construction and perfective -le. In this paper we argue that bu is not a clitic-like element and claim that it is a focussensitive operator. We propose an interpretation condition (IC) for bu that says that bu induces a tripartite structure if there is a focus to its right; otherwise it negates the adjacent word. By appealing to scope interaction, IC, and the assumption that perfective -le has a clausal scope (Pan 1993; Lin 1999), we can explain facts (i) and (ii) better than Huang (1988) and Ernst (1995).
منابع مشابه
Negative Marker bu in Chinese: its Nature and Features
The purpose of this paper is to account in a generalized way for two facts about negation in Chinese. One is that the Chinese negative marker bu cannot co-occur with the perfective aspect marker le; the other is that the Chinese negative marker bu is incompatible with the manner phrase in the V-de construction. We claim that the functional category NegP postulated by Pollock (1989) can be exten...
متن کاملArticle Title: Negation in Chinese: a Corpus-based Study Negation in Chinese: a Corpus-based Study
This article explores negation in Chinese on the basis of written and spoken corpora of Mandarin Chinese. The use of corpus data not only reveals central tendencies in language based on quantitative data, it also provides typical examples attested in authentic contexts. In this study we will first discuss negation variants in general terms, on the basis of which the focus will be shifted to the...
متن کاملSentence-Final Only and the Interpretation of Focus in Mandarin Chinese1
In this paper I document the complex interactions between the Mandarin sentence-final only item éryǐ and the focus marker shì. Following work on Chinese Sentence-Final Particles (SFP), éryǐ syntactically is in the CPdomain and thus should scope above TP-level operators such as negation, and this is indeed normally the case. However, the introduction of the focus marker shì can force the sentenc...
متن کاملSentence-Final Only and the Interpretation of Focus
In this paper I document the complex interactions between the Mandarin sentence-final only item éryǐ and the focus marker shì. Following work on Chinese Sentence-Final Particles (SFP), éryǐ syntactically is in the CPdomain and thus should scope above TP-level operators such as negation, and this is indeed normally the case. However, the introduction of the focus marker shì can force the sentenc...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2001